Dear Dr. Uchida,
Thank you for your message of May 17. Having reconsidered
your paper, 'High-efficiency photocatalyst for decomposition
of methanol solution under visible light' in the light of
the points raised in your letter, we have decided to seek
further advice on your paper. Our assessment of the paper
was based on the technical criticisms raised by the referee,
which we felt, were serious enough to prevent us from
considering your work any further. I will be in touch again
as soon as we have received additional comments.
Yours sincerely
Associate Editor
|